Football is a sport defined by its eras. Every decade delivers a team of icons who not only dominate the sport but redefine its boundaries. From the tactical evolution of tiki-taka to the high-pressing, energy-driven systems of recent years, the game has transformed — and with it, so have its superstars. In this thought experiment, we pit three distinct generations of footballing talent against each other: the iconic XI from 2010–2020, the recent best XI representing the post-2020 era, and the emerging stars shaping the future of the beautiful game.
Each lineup represents a unique moment in football’s timeline, showcasing tactical brilliance, individual flair, and collective dominance. But which team would come out on top in an epic three-way clash? Let’s break it down.
It’s Time for a Change: The Intergenerational Battle
XI: Neuer, Jordi Alba, Lahm, Varane, Sergio Ramos, Modric, Xavi, Iniesta, Messi, Benzema, Cristiano Ronaldo
The 2010s were a golden age — a time when football’s greatest-ever players shared the same pitch. This XI isn’t just a team; it’s a gallery of icons. Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi headline the attack, flanked by the creative genius of Karim Benzema. Behind them, the midfield trio of Iniesta, Xavi, and Modric represents the purest expression of footballing artistry.
Xavi and Iniesta redefined control and creativity, orchestrating Barcelona and Spain’s dynasties with surgical precision. Modric brought balance and longevity to that engine room, seamlessly connecting defence to attack. Philipp Lahm and Jordi Alba brought intelligence, overlapping runs, and defensive stability from full-back, while Sergio Ramos and Raphael Varane formed a rock-solid centre-back duo, unyielding in both domestic and European competition. Their ability to blend aggression with composure gave this team an indomitable spirit.
And in goal? Manuel Neuer — a revolutionary sweeper-keeper who blurred the line between goalkeeper and defender, setting the standard for modern-day shot-stoppers. Neuer was more than just a last line of defence; he was the foundation on which the team built its tactical superiority. His ability to initiate attacks with pinpoint passing and step out as an auxiliary defender gave his side an extra layer of control.
This team had it all — leadership, technical genius, tactical versatility, and mental fortitude. They didn’t just win matches; they defined an era and influenced the generations that followed.
It’s Time for a Change: The 2020s: Precision, Power, and Relentless Energy
XI: Courtois, Robertson, Rüdiger, Van Dijk, Carvajal, Rodri, Kroos, De Bruyne, Mbappé, Salah, Vinicius Jr.
As football moved into the 2020s, the emphasis shifted towards intensity, athleticism, and relentless execution. This team embodies modern football — a blend of raw physical power, surgical precision, and technical brilliance.
At the back, Thibaut Courtois stands tall as an imposing figure between the posts. Known for his incredible reflexes and clutch performances in big matches, Courtois is a goalkeeper who thrives under pressure. Andy Robertson and Dani Carvajal patrol the flanks tirelessly, combining defensive solidity with attacking flair. The centre-back duo of Virgil van Dijk and Antonio Rüdiger offers a near-impenetrable wall, blending aerial dominance with sharp positional awareness and unshakeable composure.
In midfield, Rodri operates as the calm metronome, breaking up play and dictating the tempo with impeccable consistency. Toni Kroos adds his versatility to operate between the lines, aiding both the defence and attack and operating as another playmaker and pace-conductor, while Kevin De Bruyne sits as the creative architect, threading impossible passes and finding space where none seems to exist.
Up front, this team boasts a terrifying attacking trident. Mohamed Salah’s consistency and lethal finishing, Kylian Mbappé’s lightning pace and flair, and Vinícius Jr who has already delivered moments of brilliance on the grandest stages. The fresh FIFA The Best Player of the Year winner has made a lot of impact for Los Blancos and is undoubtedly one of the main reasons for their recent success.
This team may lack the nuanced artistry of the 2010s XI, but their efficiency, power, and sheer relentlessness make them an unstoppable force in modern football. They don’t just overpower opponents; they dismantle them with calculated precision.
It’s Time for a Change: The Future: The Rising Stars of Tomorrow
XI: Restes, Gvardiol, Cubarsi, Saliba, Alexander-Arnold, Bellingham, Pedri, Palmer, Vinícius Jr, Yamal, Endrick
While predicting the future is always fraught with uncertainty, some players already shine brightly enough to guarantee their place among football’s elite in the years to come. The next generation is here, and they are hungry to carve their names into history.
In goal, Guillaume Restes represents the next generation of technically gifted goalkeepers — equally adept with the ball at his feet as he is with his hands. In front of him, the defensive trio of Josko Gvardiol, Pau Cubarsi, and William Saliba offers a blend of composure, physical dominance, and tactical intelligence. Trent Alexander-Arnold, already an established name, adds creativity and pinpoint passing from the right flank, serving as an auxiliary playmaker.
In midfield, Barcelona’s youngster, Pedri is the mastermind behind many of the teams attacking features and Jude Bellingham adds youthful dynamism, aggression, and goal-scoring prowess to the midfield engine, promising a bright future for both sides of El Clasico. Cole Palmer, a rising English star, brings an added layer of creativity and cool-headed finishing to the attacking setup.
The attacking trio is an exciting mix of raw talent and proven ability. Jamal Musiala has already delivered moments of brilliance for Bayern both in the Bundesilga and in the Champions League and maybe it’s time for him to take a further step to a better league to prove his quality. Lamine Yamal, still in his teens, dazzles with dribbles and composure beyond his years. Endrick, the next Brazilian wonderkid, carries the weight of expectation but possesses the flair and finishing to meet those lofty demands.
This team is raw but brimming with potential. If nurtured properly, they could surpass the achievements of their predecessors and create a new golden era.
It’s Time for a Change: The Verdict: A Clash of Eras
While the recent XI and the future XI boast undeniable talent and tactical sophistication, the 2010s team feels almost untouchable. Ronaldo, Messi, Xavi, Iniesta, and Modric aren’t just great players — they are footballing legends who changed the game forever.
The balance in the 2010s side is unparalleled. From Neuer’s revolutionary goalkeeping to the spine of Ramos, Modric, and Messi, every inch of this team exudes brilliance. They combined technique, mentality, and an unrivalled trophy haul.
If these three teams faced off, the 2010s XI would edge it — not just because of their talent, but because of their legacy. They represent a golden era in football, and their place in history remains untouchable.
But football doesn’t stand still. As the next generation rises, new legends will emerge, and the debate will start all over again. That’s the beauty of the game — its capacity for constant reinvention.
By Nicky Helfgott – NickyHelfgott1 on X (Twitter)
Keep up with all the latest football news and Premier League news on 365Scores!