Aaron Rodgers’ Legacy and the Pantheon of NFL Quarterbacks: A Definitive Ranking
While Aaron Rodgers’ plans for the 2025 season remain shrouded in mystery, his indelible mark on NFL history is undeniable. Regardless of his next move, the 41-year-old quarterback will forever be enshrined among the all-time greats whenever he chooses to retire.
Rodgers’ trophy cabinet gleams with four NFL MVP awards, a Super Bowl XLV MVP honor, and a decade of Pro Bowl selections. His journey from an overlooked high school prospect to a first-ballot Hall of Famer is a testament to his relentless drive and unparalleled skill. But where does he stand in the grand tapestry of quarterback legends? To answer this, we’ve meticulously ranked the top 30 QBs in NFL history, evaluating their accolades, records, team success, longevity, and enduring impact.
Criteria for Ranking:
- Individual Honors (MVPs, All-Pro selections)
- Record-Breaking Performances
- Team Achievements (Championships, playoff success)
- Longevity and Consistency
- Cultural and Historical Legacy
Only two active QBs made this list, though emerging stars like Josh Allen, Joe Burrow, Lamar Jackson, and Matthew Stafford are poised to join in the coming years. Eli Manning, a two-time Super Bowl MVP, also lurks on the fringe, awaiting potential Hall of Fame induction.
Honorable Mentions
George Blanda
A gridiron polymath, Blanda’s 26-year career saw him excel as a quarterback, linebacker, and kicker. His 1961 seven-touchdown game remains unmatched, and he was the first player to eclipse 2,000 career points.
Bobby Layne
The original gunslinger, Layne propelled the Lions to back-to-back titles in 1952 and 1953. His swagger revitalized the Steelers, who’d only seen two winning seasons before his 1958 arrival.
The Top 30 Quarterbacks
30. Norm Van Brocklin
A pioneer of the modern passing game, Van Brocklin led the Rams and Eagles to NFL championships, famously dethroning Vince Lombardi’s Packers in the 1960 title game.
29. Joe Namath
“Broadway Joe” immortalized himself with Super Bowl III’s iconic upset, guaranteeing victory over the Colts. His 4,000-yard 1967 season laid groundwork for the pass-happy future.
28. Warren Moon
After dominating the CFL, Moon rejuvenated the Oilers, racking seven playoff berths and back-to-back passing titles. His deep-ball artistry left him third in career yards upon retirement.
27. Philip Rivers
A model of consistency, Rivers led the league in yards, TDs, and completion percentage across different seasons. His 2007 AFC Championship grit—playing on a torn ACL—epitomized his toughness.
26. Len Dawson
The precision maestro of his era, Dawson topped completion percentages eight times. His Super Bowl IV MVP performance cemented the Chiefs’ place in history.
25. Sonny Jurgensen
The 1960s’ passing virtuoso, Jurgensen claimed five passing titles and shattered efficiency records, boasting an 82.6 rating pre-1978 rule changes.
24. Dan Fouts
Under Don Coryell’s “Air Coryell” system, Fouts unleashed four straight passing crowns and starred in the 1981 “Epic in Miami” playoff duel.
23. Jim Kelly
The architect of Buffalo’s “K-Gun” offense, Kelly reached four consecutive Super Bowls and led the NFL in completion rate (1990) and TDs (1991).
22. Sammy Baugh
The proto-modern QB, Baugh revolutionized the position with eight completion titles and a 70% season in 1945. He anchored Washington’s 1937 and 1942 championships.
21. Ken Stabler
“The Snake” blended flair with clutch play, earning 1974 MVP and piloting the Raiders’ first Super Bowl win. His “Sea of Hands” and “Holy Roller” TDs are legendary.
20. Y.A. Tittle
At 37, Tittle’s 1963 season—leading in completion %, TDs, and rating—remains a gold standard. His Giants tenure revived a fading career.
19. Kurt Warner
From grocery clerk to Super Bowl MVP, Warner’s Cinderella story included a record 414-yard Super Bowl performance and two league MVPs.
18. Ben Roethlisberger
“Big Ben” debuted with a 13-0 rookie run, won two Super Bowls with iconic throws, and ranks fifth all-time in passing yards. His 500-yard games redefined volume passing.
17. Troy Aikman
The backbone of Dallas’ 1990s dynasty, Aikman’s 70% Super Bowl accuracy stood unmatched for decades. His three rings in four years epitomized dominance.
16. Bart Starr
The Ice Bowl hero and first two-time Super Bowl MVP, Starr’s efficiency (four-time passer rating leader) powered Green Bay’s 1960s reign.
15. Fran Tarkenton
“Scrambling Fran” revolutionized mobility, guiding the Vikings to three NFC titles. He retired as the NFL’s passing leader, a title held for 17 years.
14. Roger Staubach
A late bloomer, Staubach’s 13-0 1971 campaign and “Hail Mary” legacy secured four Super Bowl trips and two rings, defining clutch play.
13. Terry Bradshaw
The Steelers’ sole MVP (1978), Bradshaw’s nine Super Bowl TDs and back-to-back titles cemented him as the 1970s’ premier big-game QB.
12. Otto Graham
A titan of early football, Graham reached 10 straight title games, winning seven. His 81.3% win rate remains unmatched among passers.
11. Steve Young
Overcoming USFL and Buccaneers struggles, Young’s dual-threat mastery yielded two MVPs, a Super Bowl record six TDs, and a then-record 96.8 passer rating.
10. Drew Brees
The epitome of precision, Brees’ seven passing titles and Super Bowl XLIV MVP fueled New Orleans’ rise. He trails only Brady in career yards and TDs.
9. Brett Favre
The ironman gunslinger, Favre’s 321 consecutive starts, three MVPs, and a Super Bowl XXXI win were overshadowed only by his risk-taking bravado.
8. Aaron Rodgers
With four MVPs and a 48:5 TD-INT ratio in 2020, Rodgers’ efficiency redefined quarterback play. His Super Bowl XLV MVP run remains a masterclass.
7. Patrick Mahomes
Already a two-time MVP and three-time Super Bowl winner, Mahomes’ 106-27 record and five AFC titles hint at a trajectory to surpass legends.
6. John Elway
“The Drive” and helicopter spin defined Elway’s grit. His back-to-back Super Bowl wins capped a career of nine Pro Bowls and five AFC crowns.
5. Johnny Unitas
The 1958 “Greatest Game Ever” hero, Unitas’ 47-game TD streak and four passing titles laid the foundation for modern QB play.
4. Dan Marino
The purest passer ever, Marino’s 5,084-yard 1984 season revolutionized offense. His quick release and records stood for decades.
3. Peyton Manning
A cerebral force with five MVPs, Manning’s 55-TD season and dual-franchise Super Bowl wins underscore his strategic genius and lasting influence.
2. Joe Montana
“Joe Cool” mastered the clutch, going 4-0 in Super Bowls with 11 TDs and zero INTs. His 92-yard drive in Super Bowl XXIII remains iconic.
1. Tom Brady
The undisputed GOAT, Brady’s seven rings, 89,214 yards, and 649 TDs dwarf all peers. His 43-year-old Super Bowl LV MVP epitomized ageless excellence.
Rodgers’ place among these titans is secure, his legacy etched in MVP brilliance and a Lombardi Trophy. As the NFL evolves, new stars will rise, but the legends above remain immortalized in football lore.
Read our previous article: Will Wade’s McNeese Legacy: NCAA Tournament Run, Records & Redemption | Full Analysis